Judging


An illustration of the Host and three judges standing side by side. They are @skippyin, @umbradoodles, @sketchy_jessie, and furpeltkishin.

Meet our panel of Judges! All auditions and rounds will be judged by Umbra, Sketch, and Furpelt. However, if the need arises and one judge is unable to perform their duty, then Skippy will fill in as back-up judge. The judges will be looking for a few key things when it comes to submissions: Legibility, Choreography, Story, and overall Spectacle. Here’s what we mean...


  • Legibility - Can we understand what is going on? Can we read all the text with no issue? Are there any spelling mistakes? Can we see the characters and their actions clearly or is the image too bright/dark/squished? Are the speech bubbles and panels arranged so they can be read in order?

  • Choreography - How well the action is composed. This is, after all, a tournament about Giant Monsters beating the crap out of each other. However, this category also applies to general actions being taken by the characters.
    Are the actions being clearly telegraphed? Is there even any action at all or are they just standing there like cardboard cutouts?

  • Story - Of course, since this is a storytelling competition, the judges will be taking a close look at the story you are trying to tell. Stuff like pacing, tone, and character progression are key things for an engaging story. If you fail to understand these things, then you won't get a very high score!
    Understand the scope of your story. And understand your characters. Consistency is key! Conflict drives a story! And please respect your opponent's OC like you would want yours to be respected.

  • Spectacle - This last one is, overall, how much the judges enjoyed reading the entry. After all, the most important thing about a good comic is for it to be fun! Did your entry manage to captivate the audience? Did your creativity really stand out? Then you'll score pretty high!

We are NOT judging you based on...

  • How good your art is.
  • How powerful your character is.
  • How serious your story is.
  • How gorey or violent your comic is.
  • The length of your submission.
  • The medium your submission uses.
  • How much you use the judge characters.
  • How accurate you portay characters that are not your own or your opponent.

Submission Requirements

We request that if you are using a traditional medium (pen, paper, etc) that you please use a scanner to make sure your entry is legible. Taking a photo with a smart phone will make it grainy, hard to read, and - if the lighting is bad - impossible to see.

If you are creating a comic digitally, then make sure your submission for that round is in ONE place. We might miss important parts of your story if you have every single page of it scattered across several different links. Websites like Cubari will be tremendously helpful! Webtoons and Tapas are also acceptable. Or you could always save your submission as a single .pdf and upload it to google docs/dropbox!

(Having your own website/blog to host the entries will also be accepted by the way. Many sites have webcomic templates.)

Lastly, if you are creating a video submission, uploading it to Youtube or Vimeo would be the most preferable option.


Prizes

Venenatis mollis torquent conubia morbi ut neque dis dapibus magna. At maecenas auctor laoreet vivamus consequat fringilla. Lectus taciti purus turpis sit auctor commodo interdum. Mi pulvinar in pulvinar lacus tempor imperdiet consectetur volutpat. Consequat varius parturient egestas interdum varius cras potenti. Pharetra consectetur gravida lobortis, nostra dictum curabitur metus magna. Purus dictum vestibulum vulputate, bibendum potenti habitasse risus.

Hendrerit tortor nulla dis amet sem porttitor penatibus. Suscipit potenti tempor fermentum nam vehicula dictum sollicitudin iaculis hac. Aenean maecenas volutpat fames tortor ipsum magnis duis litora conubia. Integer parturient viverra litora praesent finibus. Taciti magnis aliquet fermentum, elementum iaculis ultricies proin augue. Malesuada tempus sollicitudin cursus non pellentesque potenti quam hac elit. Lacus fringilla facilisi fringilla ornare, consectetur hendrerit mattis proin. Pharetra nisl bibendum ornare sagittis suspendisse praesent condimentum suscipit.

Eu adipiscing quam consequat platea morbi ut viverra. Non vivamus nam mattis maecenas fames sodales curabitur venenatis. Erat tincidunt tempor massa sagittis lacus sociosqu quam ipsum a. Faucibus mattis maecenas integer mus class imperdiet. Eleifend urna ante scelerisque laoreet torquent donec maximus lacus dictum. Ullamcorper auctor rutrum lectus arcu velit vehicula? Justo elit tempor lorem fames egestas metus per nam molestie. Nascetur rhoncus condimentum lectus taciti fusce mattis ullamcorper senectus? Massa vehicula pretium donec penatibus magna a. Vel dolor quam etiam eros placerat sed.